Child Care and Early Education Research Connections

Skip to main content

When are field experiments with individual assignment too risky?: Lessons from a center-based child care study in Guatemala

Description:
Randomized controlled trials, prized for generating unbiased estimates of treatment effects, have become popular in development economics. However, RCTs do not always offer sufficient statistical power, which is reduced in experiments with imperfect compliance to treatment assignment. This is of critical importance if effect sizes are modest, and if non-compliance may occur. Both are likely in experiments in center-based childcare programs with individual-level randomization for several reasons. Dropout in the treatment group may occur because families' demand for preschool is unknown when the sample is constructed, and it evolves over time as households experience shocks and as they learn about the center. Non-compliance in the control group arises when children access the program or alternative preschool programs. This paper uses a recent evaluation of the Hogares Comunitarios program in Guatemala to illustrate challenges inherent in experimental evaluations and offers strategies to identify situations in which studies are more likely to succeed. (author abstract)
Resource Type:
Reports & Papers
Author(s):
Country:
Guatemala

- You May Also Like

These resources share similarities with the current selection.

Universal child care: A risky experiment with our nation's children

Other

Creating better child care jobs: Model work standards for teaching staff in center-based child care (2nd ed.)

Other

Model work standards for teaching staff in center-based child care

Other
Release: 'v1.57.0' | Built: 2024-03-14 09:29:08 EDT